Natalie is Jesse's girlfriend in early 2013. She's a student at the University of Washington and lives in dorms. She is willowy with long wavy brown hair.
Jesse finds her "open to reason" and manages to convince her to be less superstitious. However, he's constantly uncertain about their relationship because she won't sleep with him.
They break up after two months. By mid-April they're back together, but during Wynter's visit to Seattle she causes them to break up for good.